How to Be Natural and Organic in a One-on-One Networking Meeting

PRINT

Hint: It’s Not a Job Interview, So Lose the Pre-Written Script!

Networking. For some, the word alone can spark anxiety, triggering visions of stiff handshakes, forced smiles, and awkward small talk that rivals the most uncomfortable family reunion. But networking doesn’t have to feel like a stuffy job interview. In fact, the secret to a successful one-on-one networking meeting isn’t in how many business cards you hand out or how perfectly you deliver your elevator pitch. It’s about being real, relatable, and, yes, natural.

So, let’s drop the formality, toss aside the robotic questions, and focus on what really matters: getting to know each other as people first, professionals second. Here’s how to master the art of organic conversation in your next networking encounter.

1. Ditch the Pre-Written Questions—They Can Smell ‘Em a Mile Away

We’ve all been there—staring at our phones, memorizing a mental list of questions we’ll use to “break the ice.” Spoiler alert: most people can tell when you’re using a pre-planned script. If it feels robotic to you, imagine how the other person must feel. There’s nothing like being asked, “So, what do you think your five-year plan is?” to make someone feel like they’ve stumbled into an impromptu job interview.

Instead, loosen up! Sure, it’s good to be prepared, but let the conversation flow. If they mention their love for a particular sport or hobby, dive into that instead of trying to reroute the conversation back to your list of business-related questions. People are much more relaxed when they’re discussing something they actually enjoy.

Pro Tip:

Think of yourself as a curious friend rather than a strategic professional. Your genuine interest in who they are as a person will naturally steer the conversation in an engaging direction. Plus, it’s way more fun than sounding like an HR questionnaire!

2. Lead with Authenticity, Not Agendas

If you walk into a networking meeting with one clear goal—whether it’s to sell something, recruit, or find your next gig—it’s going to show. And it’s going to feel awkward. The best connections often come when you don’t have a hidden agenda hanging in the background.

When your only objective is to get to know the person sitting across from you, the vibe changes. You’re not just networking for a business gain; you’re forming a genuine relationship. This takes the pressure off both you and your networking partner, and it often leads to more fruitful opportunities down the line.

Try This:

Begin by asking open-ended questions that allow the conversation to take shape naturally. A simple, “What’s your story?” is a great way to start, without steering things directly into business territory. It shows you’re interested in who they are beyond their LinkedIn profile.

3. Talk About Common Interests, Not Common Goals

This might sound counterintuitive in a professional networking setting, but not every conversation has to revolve around business, business, business. In fact, talking about non-work-related topics can build a rapport that feels more personal and lasting. Once you establish common ground—whether it’s a shared hobby, a mutual acquaintance, or even your mutual disdain for terrible coffee—the business conversations will flow more naturally from there.

It’s about making a human connection first. When that happens, the professional stuff often sorts itself out.

Break the Ice:

Instead of kicking things off with the dreaded “What do you do?”—ask something a little lighter. Maybe, “What’s the most fun project you’ve worked on recently?” or “What’s your go-to way to unwind after work?” These questions still allow room for work-related answers, but in a much more relaxed context.

4. Listen More Than You Talk (And Definitely Don’t Interrupt)

In your excitement to make a good impression, it’s easy to fall into the trap of talking too much about yourself. But guess what? People are generally more impressed by those who listen well. The trick is to focus on them rather than thinking about what you’re going to say next.

Engaged listening also gives you plenty of opportunities to naturally respond with follow-up questions that show genuine interest. This can keep the conversation going smoothly and organically, without the need for scripted questions. Plus, it makes the other person feel valued and heard.

Fun Fact:

People tend to remember how you made them feel during a conversation more than the specific words you said. So, make them feel good by truly listening!

5. Don’t Be Afraid to Show a Little Personality

This is probably the most important tip. Let your personality shine! If you’re quirky, be quirky. If you have a dry sense of humor, don’t be afraid to drop a witty comment. Authenticity goes a long way in making memorable connections. You don’t want to blend into the sea of cookie-cutter professionals who all ask the same generic questions.

Being true to who you are is not only refreshing, but it also attracts people who vibe with your energy. When you’re being yourself, you’ll naturally find commonalities with others who are on the same wavelength.

Something to Remember:

Networking isn’t about being perfect; it’s about being real. The more human you are, the more likely you’ll create lasting, meaningful connections.

6. Leave Room for Future Conversations

Networking meetings can sometimes feel like you need to squeeze every bit of information out in one sitting. But that’s not the case! It’s okay to leave a little something for next time. In fact, leaving the door open for future interactions is a smart way to keep the relationship going.

You don’t have to cover every topic under the sun or exchange every detail of your professional life in that first meeting. Just focus on building rapport, and the rest will follow.

End Gracefully:

As the meeting winds down, try something like, “I’ve really enjoyed this conversation! We should definitely grab coffee again soon and continue chatting.” It’s a friendly, non-pressure way to signal you’d like to stay connected.

In Conclusion

Networking doesn’t have to feel like a forced business transaction. In fact, it shouldn’t feel that way. The most successful networking interactions come from authentic, relaxed conversations that allow people to connect on a personal level. So, leave the scripted questions at home, focus on finding common ground, and remember—networking is just a fancy word for getting to know someone new.

And who knows? Maybe you’ll walk away with more than just a LinkedIn connection. You might make a new friend. Now, isn’t that more fun?